The Innocence Forum

Innocence Forum
Vincent Simmons

Justice For Vincent Simmons

Vincent was convicted of the rape of twin white girls and sentenced to a hundred years in prison. He has been at Angola prison for 27 years. He was convicted purely on the basis of the flawed and contradictory testimony of the two alleged victims and their cousin. There was no physical evidence of any kind against Vincent, in fact no physical evidence that the rapes ever actually occurred. The twins picked Vincent out of a line up in which he was the only one handcuffed after openly stating that all black men looked alike to them. Vincent is innocent of this crime.

  • No Physical Evidence

    • Fact # one

      There is no physical evidence that the rapes actually happened. The alleged victims had waited two weeks to report the alleged rapes. No forensic tests were carried out on either the clothing of the alleged victims, Vincent's clothing or the car in which the alleged rapes took place.

    • Fact # two

      The doctor's report did not find any signs of injury on either of the alleged victims and stated that one of the twins was a virgin two weeks after the alleged rapes. The doctor's report was not shown at the trial excerpts from the letter sent from F.P. Bordellon J.r M.D to district attorney Mr. J Eddie Knoll on June 10 1977, regarding examination of one of the alleged victims in the Vincent Simmons case. "She admits never having had intercourse before this.......... There was no bruises on her body. The vaginal examination showed that the hymen was intact and I was unable to insert one examining finger."

      Full version of both doctors' letters

  • Unreliable Witness Testimony

    • Fact # three

      Vincent was convicted on the basis of the flawed and contradictory testimonies of the two alleged victims and their male cousin. In the police reports the twins said that a black man attacked them. They said they did not know his name. In court the twins and their cousin all said the attacker had told them his name before attacking them and that his name was Simmons

  • Unreliable Eye Witness Identification

    • Fact # four

      The twin stated that all black men looked the same to them. They picked Vincent out of a line up in which he was the only one handcuffed. copy of the line up photo Vincent is the one wearing the handcuffs.

      Vincent Simmons Lineup
  • Illegal Arrest

    • Fact # five

      The police investigative reports did not include one single lead pointing to Vincent yet he was picked off the street and charged with the crime. Two reports by the same police officer written within twenty four hours of each other, give two completely different locations as the place of arrest.

    • Fact # six

      There is no indication that the police, at any point, had an official interview with Vincent or that he gave any sort of statement.

    • Fact # seven

      The arresting police officers never testified in court.

top of page